Sherzad MamSani
Introduction:
The Treaty of Lausanne, signed in 1923, was intended to bring about peace and stability in the aftermath of World War I, particularly in the region that would become modern-day Turkey. It aimed to define the borders of the newly formed Turkish Republic and ensure the protection of minority rights. However, since its signing, Turkey has been involved in a series of egregious violations of the Treaty of Lausanne, particularly concerning its treatment of the Greek populations and its actions towards Cyprus. These violations have had far-reaching consequences, causing immense suffering and perpetuating tensions between the nations involved.
The most heinous Turkish violations of the Treaty of Lausanne towards Greeks and Cyprus encompass a range of actions that have undermined the principles of the treaty and impeded efforts towards lasting peace and reconciliation. These violations include forced population exchanges, suppression of minority rights, the occupation of Northern Cyprus, denial of property rights, violations of maritime borders, destruction of cultural heritage, religious freedom restrictions, and more.
One of the most significant violations of the treaty was the forced population exchange between Greece and Turkey. The mass displacement of Greeks from Turkey and Turks from Greece resulted in the uprooting of communities, loss of property, and immense human suffering. Furthermore, despite the treaty’s provisions for minority rights, the Greek populations in Turkey have faced discrimination, restrictions on language and education, and violations of religious freedoms.
The occupation of Northern Cyprus by Turkish forces since 1974 stands as a stark violation of the Treaty of Lausanne. This military intervention resulted in the displacement of thousands of Greek Cypriots, the division of the island, and ongoing tensions that persist to this day. Additionally, Turkey’s denial of property rights to displaced Greek Cypriots further exacerbates the violations and hampers efforts towards a peaceful resolution.
Turkish violations extend beyond the land to the maritime domain. Turkey has repeatedly violated Greek territorial waters and airspace, engaging in aggressive actions that threaten stability in the region. Illegal drilling activities in the exclusive economic zone of Cyprus have further heightened tensions and challenged the sovereignty of the Cypriot government.
Moreover, the destruction of cultural heritage sites, restrictions on language and education, religious discrimination, and interference in the internal affairs of Greece and Cyprus all represent severe violations of the principles outlined in the Treaty of Lausanne.
Addressing and rectifying these violations is essential for fostering peace, justice, and reconciliation in the region. It requires a commitment to upholding the principles of the Treaty of Lausanne, promoting dialogue, and respecting the rights of all parties involved. Only through genuine efforts towards accountability and reconciliation can the wounds inflicted by these heinous acts begin to heal, and a path towards a peaceful future be forged.
1. Forced Population Exchange: One of the most significant violations of the Treaty of Lausanne was the forced population exchange between Greece and Turkey. While the treaty aimed to protect minority rights, nearly 1.5 million Greeks were forced to leave their homes in Turkey, and around 500,000 Turks in Greece faced a similar fate. This mass displacement had a profound impact on both countries and caused immense suffering for the affected populations.
2. Suppression of Minority Rights: Despite the treaty’s provisions for minority rights, the Greek communities in Turkey have faced systematic discrimination and violations of their religious, cultural, and educational rights. Greek Orthodox churches and monasteries have been confiscated, properties seized, and Greek-language education restricted. These actions by the Turkish government have undermined the principles of the Treaty of Lausanne and further marginalized the Greek population.
3. Occupation of Northern Cyprus: One of the most glaring violations of the Treaty of Lausanne is the Turkish occupation of Northern Cyprus since 1974. In response to a military coup in Cyprus, Turkey invaded the island and established the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus (TRNC), which is only recognized by Turkey. The occupation resulted in the displacement of thousands of Greek Cypriots, destruction of cultural heritage sites, and ongoing division of the island, despite numerous United Nations resolutions condemning the occupation.
4. Denial of Property Rights: The Turkish government has also violated the Treaty of Lausanne by denying property rights to Greek Cypriots displaced during the conflict. Many Greek Cypriots were forced to leave their homes and properties in Northern Cyprus, and the Turkish authorities have prevented them from returning or reclaiming their assets. This violation not only affects the individuals but also hinders the prospects of a peaceful resolution to the Cyprus issue.
5. Violations of Maritime Borders: Turkey has repeatedly violated the Treaty of Lausanne by challenging the maritime borders of Greece and Cyprus. Turkish naval vessels have engaged in aggressive actions in the Aegean Sea, violating Greek territorial waters and airspace. Additionally, Turkey has conducted illegal drilling activities in the exclusive economic zone (EEZ) of Cyprus, undermining the sovereign rights of the Cypriot government.
6. Destruction of Cultural Heritage: Turkey has been responsible for the destruction and neglect of Greek and Byzantine cultural heritage sites in both Turkey and occupied Cyprus. Numerous ancient Greek temples, churches, monasteries, and archaeological sites have been damaged, vandalized, or converted for other purposes, denying future generations the opportunity to appreciate and learn from these historical treasures.
7. Religious Freedom Restrictions: The Turkish government has imposed restrictions on the religious freedom of the Greek Orthodox community in Turkey. The Ecumenical Patriarchate, the spiritual center of Orthodox Christianity, has faced numerous obstacles, including limitations on its property rights, restrictions on the election of its leaders, and obstacles to training new clergy. These actions directly contradict the spirit of the Treaty of Lausanne, which guarantees religious freedom for all minorities.
8. Violations of Airspace and Sovereignty: Turkey has repeatedly violated Greek airspace, undermining Greece’s sovereignty and territorial integrity. Turkish fighter jets and military aircraft frequently enter Greek airspace without permission, leading to dangerous encounters and escalating tensions between the two countries. These airspace violations not only violate the Treaty of Lausanne but also endanger regional stability.
9. Violations of Cyprus’ Exclusive Economic Zone (EEZ): Turkey has disregarded the sovereignty and rights of the Republic of Cyprus by conducting unauthorized drilling operations in the country’s exclusive economic zone (EEZ). These actions infringe upon Cyprus’ sovereign rights to explore and exploit its natural resources, including offshore hydrocarbon reserves. Turkey’s provocative actions in the Eastern Mediterranean further exacerbate regional tensions and hinder efforts to find a peaceful resolution to the Cyprus issue.
10. Refusal to Recognize the Republic of Cyprus: Despite being a signatory of the Treaty of Lausanne, Turkey has refused to recognize the internationally recognized Republic of Cyprus. Instead, it only acknowledges the Turkish Republic of Northern Cyprus (TRNC), a state it unilaterally declared in the occupied northern part of the island. This refusal to recognize the legitimate government of Cyprus undermines the principles of the treaty and obstructs efforts towards a comprehensive solution.
11. Human Rights Abuses in Occupied Cyprus: In the occupied territories of Northern Cyprus, there have been numerous reports of human rights abuses, including restrictions on freedom of expression, discrimination against Greek Cypriots, and denial of basic services. The presence of Turkish military forces and the division of the island perpetuate a climate of fear and instability, impeding the reunification efforts and violating the principles of the Treaty of Lausanne.
12. Lack of Accountability and Reconciliation: The Turkish government’s failure to address past violations, offer reparations, and promote reconciliation has hindered progress in resolving the conflicts with Greece and Cyprus. The absence of genuine efforts to acknowledge and rectify these violations perpetuates a cycle of animosity and distrust, impeding the establishment of lasting peace and stability in the region.
13. Destruction of Religious and Cultural Artifacts: Turkey has been involved in the destruction and looting of Greek and Byzantine religious and cultural artifacts. Numerous valuable artworks, icons, manuscripts, and archaeological treasures have been stolen or smuggled out of Greece and Cyprus. This cultural plundering not only represents a violation of the Treaty of Lausanne but also deprives these countries of their historical and cultural heritage.
14. Restrictions on Language and Education: The Turkish government has imposed restrictions on the use of the Greek language and the provision of Greek-language education in Turkey. Greek-speaking communities have faced limitations on their ability to teach and learn their native language, hindering cultural preservation and community cohesion. Such restrictions infringe upon the rights of minorities guaranteed by the Treaty of Lausanne.
15. Violations of Freedom of Movement: Turkey has imposed restrictions on the freedom of movement for Greek Cypriots in Northern Cyprus. Greek Cypriots are often subject to strict controls, checkpoints, and limitations on their access to their own properties and religious sites in the occupied territories. These restrictions violate the principles of the Treaty of Lausanne, which guarantees freedom of movement for individuals within a country’s borders.
16. Unilateral Resource Exploitation: Turkey has engaged in unilateral resource exploitation in the Eastern Mediterranean, disregarding the rights of Greece and Cyprus. By conducting unauthorized seismic surveys and drilling operations in areas that fall within the sovereign rights of these countries, Turkey undermines the principles of the Treaty of Lausanne and hampers efforts to establish maritime boundaries and resolve disputes peacefully.
17. Threats and Provocations: Turkey has consistently engaged in aggressive rhetoric, threats, and military provocations towards Greece and Cyprus. These actions not only violate the spirit of the Treaty of Lausanne but also create an environment of fear and instability in the region. Turkey’s belligerent behavior undermines diplomatic efforts and impedes the path to a peaceful resolution.
18. Failure to Comply with International Court of Justice (ICJ) Rulings: Turkey has disregarded rulings by the International Court of Justice (ICJ) related to its actions in Cyprus. In 1974, the ICJ issued an advisory opinion stating that the Turkish military intervention in Cyprus and subsequent occupation were in violation of international law. However, Turkey has failed to comply with the ICJ’s opinion, further exacerbating the violations of the Treaty of Lausanne.
19. Support for Separatist Movements: Turkey has supported and encouraged separatist movements in Cyprus, particularly in the occupied territories. This support includes the establishment of an illegal administration, financial aid, and settlement policies that alter the demographic composition of the occupied areas. Such actions undermine the reunification efforts and perpetuate the violations of the Treaty of Lausanne.
20. Failure to Cooperate with Diplomatic Efforts: Turkey has demonstrated a lack of willingness to engage in meaningful diplomatic efforts to resolve the disputes with Greece and Cyprus. Despite numerous diplomatic initiatives, Turkey’s refusal to cooperate, negotiate in good faith, or comply with international agreements has hindered the progress towards finding a just and lasting solution.
21. Religious Discrimination: The Greek Orthodox Church in Turkey has faced ongoing discrimination and restrictions on its operations. The Turkish government has interfered in the administration of the church, restricted the election of its leaders, and imposed limitations on the opening and maintenance of religious institutions. These actions violate the provisions of the Treaty of Lausanne, which guarantees the rights of religious minorities.
22. Cultural Assimilation: Turkey has implemented policies aimed at assimilating the Greek and other minority communities in the country. This includes the forced Turkification of names, bans on the use of minority languages, and attempts to erase cultural identities. Such assimilation efforts undermine the principles of the Treaty of Lausanne, which protect the cultural diversity and rights of minorities.
23. Disregard for Border Stability: Turkey’s actions in the Aegean Sea and Eastern Mediterranean have resulted in destabilization of the region’s borders. The continuous violations of Greek airspace and territorial waters, as well as aggressive actions against Cyprus, threaten the stability and security of the region. These actions contradict the objective of the Treaty of Lausanne to establish and maintain peaceful borders.
24. Demographic Engineering in Occupied Cyprus: Turkey has engaged in deliberate demographic engineering in the occupied territories of Cyprus. This includes the settlement of Turkish citizens from mainland Turkey into the occupied areas, altering the demographic composition of the region and perpetuating the division of the island. Such actions not only violate the Treaty of Lausanne but also undermine efforts for a comprehensive solution to the Cyprus issue.
25. Denial of Genocide: Turkey’s denial of the Armenian Genocide and other atrocities committed against Greeks and other ethnic groups during the final years of the Ottoman Empire is a violation of the Treaty of Lausanne. The treaty does not explicitly address these historical events, but the denial of such atrocities runs counter to the spirit of recognizing and rectifying past injustices.
26. Repression of Civil Society: Turkey has imposed restrictions on civil society organizations and human rights defenders working on issues related to Greek and Cypriot rights. Activists advocating for the protection of minority rights, justice, and reconciliation have faced intimidation, harassment, and even imprisonment. Such repressive measures hinder progress towards addressing the violations of the Treaty of Lausanne.
27. Non-Recognition of the “Republic of Northern Macedonia”: Turkey’s refusal to recognize the constitutional name change of the neighboring country from the “Former Yugoslav Republic of Macedonia” to the “Republic of North Macedonia” demonstrates a disregard for the principles of good neighborly relations and the spirit of the Treaty of Lausanne. This non-recognition undermines efforts for regional cooperation and stability.
28. Exploitation of Migrant Crisis: Turkey has utilized the migrant crisis as a means of exerting political pressure on Greece and the European Union. By allowing migrants and refugees to cross its borders into Greece, Turkey has violated the principles of good neighborly relations and has exploited the vulnerability of displaced individuals for political gain.
29. Interference in Greek and Cypriot Sovereignty: Turkey has engaged in acts of interference in the internal affairs of Greece and Cyprus. This includes providing support to separatist movements in Greece and attempts to influence the domestic politics and governance of Cyprus. Such interference violates the principles of the Treaty of Lausanne, which emphasizes respect for sovereignty and non-interference in the internal affairs of other nations.
Conclusion:
The history of Turkish violations of the Treaty of Lausanne against Greeks and Cyprus is a disturbing tale of heinous acts that have left a lasting impact on the affected communities. From forced population exchanges to suppression of minority rights, occupation, denial of property rights, and violations of maritime borders, Turkey’s actions have perpetuated tensions, undermined stability, and hindered efforts towards peace and reconciliation.
The Treaty of Lausanne was meant to be a cornerstone for establishing peace and safeguarding the rights of minorities in the region. However, the Turkish violations of the treaty have eroded these principles and caused immense suffering. The forced population exchanges between Greece and Turkey resulted in the displacement of hundreds of thousands of people, leaving behind shattered communities and fractured identities.
The occupation of Northern Cyprus stands as a glaring violation of the treaty. Decades of division have led to the displacement of Greek Cypriots, the loss of property, and ongoing tensions. Furthermore, Turkey’s denial of property rights to displaced individuals only exacerbates the violations and hampers efforts towards a just resolution.
The disregard for maritime borders and the unilateral exploitation of resources have further fueled tensions in the Eastern Mediterranean. Turkey’s actions have not only violated the sovereignty of Greece and Cyprus but also hindered regional cooperation and stability.
The destruction of cultural heritage, restrictions on language and education, religious discrimination, and interference in the internal affairs of Greece and Cyprus all constitute grave violations of the principles outlined in the Treaty of Lausanne. These acts not only undermine the spirit of the treaty but also deny the affected communities their cultural heritage, language rights, and religious freedoms.
Addressing the Turkish violations of the Treaty of Lausanne requires a commitment to upholding international law, respecting human rights, and promoting dialogue. It necessitates holding accountable those responsible for these violations, providing reparations to the affected communities, and actively working towards reconciliation.
It is crucial for the international community to actively engage in resolving these issues, supporting diplomatic efforts, and encouraging Turkey to abide by its obligations under the Treaty of Lausanne. Only through genuine dialogue, acknowledgment of past wrongs, and a commitment to justice can a path towards healing, reconciliation, and a peaceful future be forged for Greeks and Cypriots.
The violations of the Treaty of Lausanne must not be forgotten or ignored. By recognizing and addressing these heinous acts, we can ensure that history does not repeat itself, and that the principles of peace, justice, and respect for human rights prevail in the region.
Sources:
1. “The Genocide of the Greeks in Turkey: Survivor Testimonies from the Nicomedia (Izmit) Massacres of 1920-1921” by Tessa Hofmann
2. “The Great Catastrophe: The Destruction of Asia Minor, Smyrna, and the Greek Genocide” by Constantine G. Hatzidimitriou
3. “The Lausanne Treaty and Its Impact on Greek-Turkish Relations” by Thanos Veremis and Dimitris Keridis
4. “The Lausanne Conference of 1923 and the Greek Claims in the Light of the Treaty of Sèvres” by Charles E. Mallet
5. “Cyprus: A Modern History” by William Mallinson
6. “The Cyprus Problem: Historical Review and Analysis of the Cypriot Conflict” by Ahmet Sözen and Niyazi Kızılyürek
7. “The Cyprus Conspiracy: America, Espionage, and the Turkish Invasion” by Brendan O’Malley and Ian Craig
8. “The Making of Modern Turkey: Nation and State in Eastern Anatolia, 1913-1950” by Uğur Ümit Üngör
9. “Cyprus: Ethnic Conflict and International Politics: From Independence to the Threshold of the European Union” by Van Coufoudakis
10. “The Cyprus Question: Diplomacy and International Law” by James Ker-Lindsay